Interestingly, I've read several raving review. But yeah, I didn't feel it either. It wasn't a bad episode, it just didn't have the emotional punch for me.

I liked the Lainie/Sam vibe. I wish they'd made her a bit older so there might have been a bit of a romance. Oh well. Or, maybe I'm just a perve. *L*

I've also read that John saying "ILY" to Dean was a sure sign that it wasn't John.