not knowing the specific circumstances of a possible relationship makes any arguments for or against not terribly important until we get a canon clarification.
Ah. See, to me, that's what we do allatime, we discuss and argue about things that aren't 100% clear from canon. Fandom is constantly talking about "what if" and "do you think [this or that]" or "if John missed all those Christmases he's a terrible father" / "no he isn't, he was out there trying to save people and that trumps Christmas" and so on. I'm really bewildered why this one situation has so many people saying that we shouldn't have opinions about a "if he is/if he isn't" until we know for sure whether he is or isn't.
If Sam is engaging in a sexual relationship, with a demon who is housed with a body that does not have it's original occupant in a lock down.. I respectfully submit that it could be some very interesting story.
I agree. If the girl is no longer in the body, then sure -- though I'd be interested to know how Sam could be convinced that it was true, since everything we know so far says that the soul is still in the body even after the body should be dead.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Re: I believe the fact is that there is a large question
Date: 2008-10-18 01:53 pm (UTC)Ah. See, to me, that's what we do allatime, we discuss and argue about things that aren't 100% clear from canon. Fandom is constantly talking about "what if" and "do you think [this or that]" or "if John missed all those Christmases he's a terrible father" / "no he isn't, he was out there trying to save people and that trumps Christmas" and so on. I'm really bewildered why this one situation has so many people saying that we shouldn't have opinions about a "if he is/if he isn't" until we know for sure whether he is or isn't.
If Sam is engaging in a sexual relationship, with a demon who is housed with a body that does not have it's original occupant in a lock down.. I respectfully submit that it could be some very interesting story.
I agree. If the girl is no longer in the body, then sure -- though I'd be interested to know how Sam could be convinced that it was true, since everything we know so far says that the soul is still in the body even after the body should be dead.